What affects the cost of my vehicle insurance quote?

Jun 26, 2025

Are you a vehicle owner in Canada wondering why your car insurance quote feels higher than expected? You’re not alone. For many Canadians, car insurance is a major monthly cost. And if your premium has climbed recently, it can be frustrating to figure out what caused the change. The truth is, car insurance rates have been going up across the country. It’s not always easy to tell why, but once you understand the key factors insurers look at, the picture becomes much clearer. Here, we will share the main reasons why your insurance rate may be higher than expected—and what you can do about it.

 

  1. Your driving profile

    Insurers build your rate based on how you drive, how long you’ve been driving, and what your history behind the wheel says about your risk level.

    • Age and experience

      Insurers build your rate based on how you drive, how long you’ve been driving, and what your history behind the wheel says about your risk level.

    • Driving record

      Speeding tickets, distracted driving, or accidents on your record will bump up your premium. Even smaller infractions can nudge your rate higher, while more serious ones—like a DUI—can send it through the roof.

    • Claims history

      If you’ve made insurance claims in the past, especially multiple ones, insurers might view you as a higher risk. Some provinces protect you from rate hikes if you weren’t at fault, but not all insurers handle this the same way.

  2. Credit score

    Yes, some insurers in Canada use your credit score when calculating your rate. It helps them predict the likelihood of a claim or missed payment. They need your permission to check it, and you can refuse, but knowing your score beforehand can help you prepare.

  3. Your vehicle matters

    Not all vehicles cost the same to insure. What you drive plays a huge role in shaping your quote.

    • Make, model, and year

      Luxury cars, sports cars, and models that are expensive to repair or replace usually come with higher premiums. On the other hand, vehicles with a good track record for reliability and safety tend to be cheaper to insure.

    • Safety features

      Cars that include systems such as anti-lock brakes, blind-spot monitoring, and automatic emergency braking might earn you a discount. These features reduce the risk of injury and damage in a collision.

    • Anti-theft protection

      Auto theft is on the rise in Canada. If your car has built-in theft protection—such as a factory alarm, immobilizer, or tracking device—your insurer might reward you with a lower rate.

    • Repair costs (CLEAR system)

      Insurers use data to figure out how expensive a vehicle is to fix or replace. This system, called CLEAR, helps them estimate how likely a claim is and what it might cost. If your car is less costly to fix, you’ll probably pay less for insurance.

    • Electric vehicles (EVs)

      EVs can sometimes cost more to insure. While they’re great for the environment—and some insurers offer “green” discounts—they often come with pricier parts and fewer repair shops, which can push premiums higher.

  4. Where you live and drive

    Your location plays a surprisingly big role in your insurance rate.

    • City vs. country

      If you live in a busy city with lots of traffic and higher theft rates, your insurance will likely be more expensive than someone in a quiet rural area.

    • Neighbourhood stats

      Insurers look at accident and theft data by postal code. If your area has more incidents, your rate could go up. It’s a good idea to check your neighbourhood’s trends when comparing quotes.

    • Commute and car use

      The more you drive, the greater your chances of having an accident. So, if you use your car daily for a long commute, expect a higher rate than someone who just drives occasionally on weekends.

  5. Coverage and deductibles

    What you choose to include in your policy directly affects your monthly cost.

    • Comprehensive vs. basic

      Basic insurance only covers damage you cause to others. Comprehensive coverage protects against things like theft, vandalism, and weather-related damage too—but it costs more.

    • Higher deductibles

      Opting for a higher deductible can reduce your monthly premium, but it means you'll need to cover more costs yourself if you ever file a claim. It’s important to weigh this carefully and choose an amount you’d feel confident paying in an unexpected situation.

Some things are out of your hands but still affect your rate.

  • Inflation plays a significant role in rising insurance costs. As prices go up across the board, the cost of fixing or replacing a vehicle climbs too. Car parts are more expensive, skilled labour demands higher wages, and even temporary replacement vehicles during repairs add to the total claim value. When insurers face larger claim payouts, they raise premiums to balance out their own costs. It doesn’t happen overnight, but the effect shows up steadily over time—and every driver ends up feeling it.
  • Auto theft and fraud also push insurance costs higher. When a stolen vehicle claim is filed, insurers must pay to replace the car, which can amount to tens of thousands of dollars. The more frequently this happens, the more insurers need to collect in premiums to stay financially sound. Fraud adds another layer. Staged accidents, exaggerated claims, or dishonest repair invoices all contribute to higher overall claim costs. These losses are shared across the insurance pool, which means even drivers who have never filed a claim may still see their premiums rise.
  • Supply chain delays are another hidden pressure point. When essential car parts are hard to find or slow to arrive, vehicles stay in repair shops longer. This can lead to extended rental car usage and more costly repair bills. Insurers have to account for these longer timelines and higher expenses in their pricing models. The result? Higher premiums for policyholders.
  • Severe weather events have become more common, and they bring significant damage with them. From hailstorms and floods to wildfires and ice storms, these incidents result in a flood of comprehensive claims. Insurers spread that risk across all customers. So even if your car hasn’t been directly damaged, living in a region prone to extreme weather can increase your rate.

Choose the best vehicle insurance for your car

At Begin Insurance, we understand that every driver’s needs are different. Whether you use your car for daily commuting, weekend getaways, or business, your insurance should reflect how you drive and what you value most—affordability, protection, or peace of mind. That’s why we take a personalized approach to help you find coverage that fits your vehicle, your lifestyle, and your budget.

Our team works with you to explore options, explain coverage clearly, and uncover discounts you might not know about. Whether you’re insuring a brand-new SUV, an electric vehicle, or a dependable sedan, we’re here to help you make smart, informed choices. To know more, get in touch with us.

 

Get A Quick Quote

Latest Articles
Car Insurance for Multiple Drivers in Family How do I find the best insurance for my family? We are... Previous
Next
Comments
Get a free quote